Georgia Supreme Court Provides Clarification on Standard of Review in Health Department Cases

Vacated on Appeal: Ruling Clarifies Standard of Review

Atlanta, United States: The Supreme Court of Georgia has explicated the standard of review that the commissioner of the Georgia Department of Community Health must utilize when inspecting a judgement of a hearing officer concerning an application for a certificate of need, or CON, to introduce a new health service at a hospital.

A Turnaround in the Court Procedure

Former Commissioner Frank Berry had overturned a hearing officer’s denial of a CON for a hospital project expansion. However, rather than deciding if Berry’s reversal contained “competent substantial evidence,” as was the issue at hand, the Justices clarified that the meaning of the phrase in OCGA § 31-6-44(k)(1) is actually understood to denote substantial evidence that was admissible. This implies that the phrase is suggestive of a standard that does not allow the commissioner to reassess the evidence, scrutinize the credibility of witnesses, or displace his judgment on factual issues for that of the hearing officer based upon the commissioner’s proficiency.

Previous Cases and Further Investigation

This decision follows a series of courtroom debates over the authority of the commissioner, with the hospital’s initial certificate of need being vacated previously. Various litigations have been focusing on whether an intermediate appellate court erred in determining the expression ‘competent substantial

Author: HERE Atlanta

HERE Atlanta

Share
Published by
HERE Atlanta

Recent Posts

Washington D.C. Braces for Matt Gaetz as Attorney General: What’s Next?

Washington D.C. Braces for Matt Gaetz as Attorney General: What's Next? **Washington D.C.** has been…

11 hours ago

New Jersey Faces Drought Warning Amid Increasing Wildfire Risks

New Jersey Faces Drought Warning Amid Wildfire Threat As New Jersey grapples with an alarming…

11 hours ago

FBI Raids Shayne Coplan’s Home Amid Polymarket Inquiry

Shayne Coplan's Home Raided by FBI in Polymarket Investigation New York City—Early Wednesday morning, the…

11 hours ago

Atlanta Welcomes Three New Event Venues to West Midtown for Unforgettable Celebrations

Exciting News for Event Lovers in Atlanta! Hey there, Atlanta! The buzz in town is…

12 hours ago

Slim Chickens Set to Expand with Ten New Locations Across Georgia!

Exciting News for Chicken Lovers in Georgia! Hello, chicken fans! If you’re in Georgia, get…

12 hours ago

Discover the Best of Atlanta: A Comprehensive Guide to Your Next Adventure

Explore the Vibrant City of Atlanta: Your Guide to Unforgettable Experiences If you find yourself…

12 hours ago